Science
and Knowledge:
Obstacles to Islam
According to legend, when the caliph Umar conquered Alexandria
in the seventh century, he had the famous and vast library
destroyed, saying that if the writings contained within were in
agreement with the Koran, then they were redundant and therefore
useless; if they disagree with the holy book of the Muslims, then
they are blasphemous and must be burned. It turns out that this
apocryphal story was not invented by critics of Islam but rather
was created by Muslims of the twelfth century to justify the
burning of other heretical texts.
The centuries provide many such examples of Islam's deliberate
turning-away from knowledge and human rights, a very common
phenomenon in other world religions. The Koran, for example,
accepts slavery as an institution, even more so than the Bible. It
should be noted that the Muslims are bidden to be kind to their
slaves, and to free a slave is considered a great act of kindness.
However, under Islam, slaves are merely property and have no legal
rights whatsoever. Black slaves especially were treated with total
contempt and disdain by ancient Muslims. In fact, black slaves
existed in the Muslim world into the twentieth century - some
sources report that thousands of blacks are kidnapped from Africa
each year and reduced to slavery in Middle Eastern Muslim
households.
The study of "foreign" sciences - that is, subjects
like mathematics, philosophy, natural history, medicine, and
astronomy - was looked upon with great suspicion and occasionally
open hostility, especially during the Middle Ages. These foreign
sciences were allegedly a threat to Islam, as they came largely
from non-Muslim sources. Ibn Warraq quotes one non-Muslim scholar
as suggesting that science and philosophy flourished on Muslim
soil during the first half of the middles ages; but it was not by
reason of Islam, it was in spite of Islam. Not a Muslim
philosopher or scholar escaped persecution. To give Islam the
credit for [Ahmad ibn Rushd] and so many other illustrious
thinkers, who passed half their life in prison, in forced hiding,
in disgrace, whose books were burned and whose writings almost
suppressed by theological authority, is as if one were to ascribe
to the Inquisition the discoveries of Galileo, and a whole
scientific development which it was not able to prevent.
The twelfth-century Arabian scientist Ibn al-Haitham asserted
that the earth was spherical, not flat. His work was castigated as
heretical and his books were burned. Carl Sagan updates this
Muslim aversion to a spherical Earth in his 1996 book The
Demon-Haunted World:
In 1993, the supreme religious authority of Saudi Arabia, Sheik
Abdel-Aziz Ibn Baaz, issued an edict, or fatwa, declaring that the
world is flat. Anyone of the round persuasion does not believe in
God and should be punished. Among many ironies, the lucid evidence
that the Earth is a sphere, accumulated by the second-century
Graeco-Roman astronomer Claudies Ptolemaeus, was transmitted to
the West by astronomers who were Muslim and Arab.
In Islam, any study that is not essential to the furtherance of
the cause is deemed unnecessary and therefore forbidden. Biology
and paleontology, for example, is largely ignored by believers
since discoveries in those areas would hinder Islam rather than
promote it, e.g. the development of heretical evolutionary theory.
Copy And Pasted from Islamanics!
If
you enjoyed this article, please visit: http://www.hinduunity.org
|